Will the show stick to Part II’s most divisive story beats (and ending) or diverge to surprise fans in Season 3?

Adapting Controversy: Will The Last of Us Series Dare Repeat Part II’s Wildest Story Beats?

So, here we are, fellow survivors – right at the edge of the world again. As the spores settle and clickers prowl the distant corners of our imagination, The Last of Us series stands, bat in hand, ready to swing hard with Season 3. The real question burning in every fan’s mind though: are the showrunners really going to follow The Last of Us Part II’s most controversial footsteps, or are they about to surprise us all with some wild, off-script energy?

Turning Up the Heat: Will the Show Go Full Part II?

Let’s cut right to the chase. Craig Mazin and Neil Druckmann — the show’s creators and also your guides through this emotional minefield — already dropped a juicy hint. They’ve said (crystal clear, by the way) that they don’t plan to leap past the game’s storyline. Mazin himself told interviewers, “I am not going to go past the game. I’ll just say that flat out.” That’s not just some throwaway line. He means it. So buckle up, because the show intends to faithfully mirror the game, sharp edges, heartbreak, and all.

Season 2 proved those weren’t just empty words. Remember the uproar over Joel? The show didn’t water it down, didn’t pull punches. Joel met his grim fate right on schedule, and fans felt every agonizing beat. Abby? She stepped in, swinging her narrative bat hard, and the internet’s opinion divided faster than Fireflies in a power struggle. Even Kaitlyn Dever, the actor cast as Abby, knows she’s at the eye of a very fired-up storm.

Abby’s Big Moment: Get Ready to Feel Everything

Now, on to the thundercloud itself: Abby. Say her name in a room full of Part II fans and you’ll get all the opinions — sometimes at once.

Word from the production is that Season 3 will spin around Abby’s journey. In plain terms, Catherine O’Hara (Gail in the series) went ahead and stated, “It’s the Abby story.” Well, that’s about as subtle as a pipe bomb. The show wants to immerse us in Abby’s world — the battles she fights, the trauma she carries, and yes, the moral hot mess of it all.

Fans of the game remember how once you flip the controller to play as Abby, things get complicated fast. Suddenly, Joel’s actions land differently. Loyalty blurs. As the show inches closer to this fork in the road, Mazin keeps backing up the narrative risk. “Abby is the hero of her story,” he explained, looking to challenge our expectations and drag us, willing or not, into Abby’s shoes.

A look at how the writers might tackle the game’s controversial moments.

Audience Reaction: You Thought the Internet Was Mad Before?

Let’s talk about the, well, seismic ripple the game caused. You probably couldn’t go on social media for weeks after Part II dropped without scrolling into angry threads or long, emotional essays. When Season 2 of the show mirrored those moments, some fans felt vindicated, while others definitely weren’t shy about their rage.

And this isn’t just gut feeling — numbers back it up. Rotten Tomatoes saw the audience score for Season 2 drop to 39%, a sharp plunge from the soaring 86% Season 1 enjoyed. Some cited those same controversial beats: Joel’s fate, the focus on Abby, and the willingness of the writers to let beloved characters make ugly, terrible, raw choices. If the plan sticks, Season 3 is on course to follow this earthquake all the way through. But the creators? They don’t seem interested in changing course to chase likes — they want to stick to the narrative they believe in, whatever the risk.

How The Writers Are Reworking Controversy

But here’s where things get interesting: the showrunners aren’t simply copy-pasting the game scene by scene. They’ve reimagined the pace, especially around Abby’s backstory. The goal? Build up enough empathy so viewers can ride those emotional waves and maybe, just maybe, understand Abby before the internet fires up another round of debates.

Neil Druckmann, never one to let the moment slip, confirmed this approach. “We needed to earn Abby emotionally from the start.” It’s clever, really. By weaving Abby’s perspective in gradually, the show gets to sidestep one of the game’s biggest triggers for outrage: the jarring, abrupt shift to Abby after hours in Ellie’s shoes. An earlier introduction means viewers won’t feel like the narrative rug has been yanked out from under them.

Expect more of this non-linear storytelling in Season 3. The creative team’s keen to keep us guessing by jumping around in time — flashbacks, flashforwards, and those quieter moments where the characters reveal just how broken (or maybe resilient) they’re feeling.

Divisive, Yes. But Unapologetic

Dig around a bit in recent cast interviews, and you’ll notice a theme: no one’s apologizing for the show’s direction. The press tour for the Season 2 finale, in fact, made it clear: The Last of Us stands by its own difficult truths.

Kaitlyn Dever, taking on Abby, spoke recently about playing such a hot-button role, saying, “I understand how much the story means to fans, and how complicated Abby is. But that’s what excites me.” And she’s not alone. Pedro Pascal and Bella Ramsey — both returning for the chaos — also openly back the creators’ choice to dive straight into those controversial moments instead of tiptoeing around them for safer storytelling.

Why Not Just Change the Ending?

Let’s address the wild card — could HBO rewrite the whole ending, just to keep fans happy? Consider this wishful thinking for now. Mazin and Druckmann, from everything we know, have a very stubborn integrity about adapting the core narrative. They see the fury over Joel’s murder, and the divided reception to Abby, not as problems to fix, but as the very lifeblood of the story.

In many ways, they view controversy as a feature, not a bug. It’s the very thing that keeps the show pulsing with urgency and unpredictability. Mazin himself once joked, “If we’re doing our jobs right, people will yell at their TVs.” Honestly, job done.

Season 3 — Ready for More Pain?

We know from numerous interviews and leaks that production for Season 3 will lean even harder into emotional gut punches. There’s talk of more flashbacks to the years after Joel’s death, showing both Ellie and Abby’s grief and anger. And the supporting cast? No one’s safe. Returning and new faces alike are all about to be dragged into the tangled web of revenge and regret.

  • Don’t expect safe, sunny closure for these characters.
  • Don’t expect the show to tiptoe around divisive plot points or soften blow after blow.
  • Instead, gear up for more gut-twisting choices, journeys through trauma, and those classic HBO-style “can you believe they just went there?” moments.

So Why Watch — If It Hurts So Good?

At the end of the day, what makes The Last of Us special isn’t that it makes things easy. It’s the way the show pulls us into these blistering, uncomfortable spaces where we’re forced to question our own morals. By sticking to the game’s most controversial elements, the series won’t just surprise viewers — it’ll provoke, challenge, and maybe, somewhere in the lingering aftermath of a major character death, connect us all.

Love it or hate it, you can’t look away. And honestly? That’s exactly where The Last of Us has always wanted us — caught between heartbreak and hope, cussing at the screen, hungry for one more flicker of light in the dark.

Catch you all next fungal outbreak, folks. You’re going to need all the empathy you can muster for what comes next.

Molly Grimes
Molly Grimes

Molly Grimes is a dedicated TV show blogger and journalist celebrated for her sharp insights and captivating commentary on the ever-evolving world of entertainment. With a talent for spotting hidden gems and predicting the next big hits, Molly's reviews have become a trusted source for TV enthusiasts seeking fresh perspectives. When she's not binge-watching the latest series, she's interviewing industry insiders and uncovering behind-the-scenes stories.

Articles: 32